5 Signs You Need to Change Your Skincare Routine (And Why It Doesn’t Always Mean Buying New Products)

Woman researching how to change her skincare routine
Woman researching how to change her skincare routine

When people say “change your skincare routine,” the first instinct is to toss everything and start from scratch. But that’s not always the right move. Sometimes, the problem isn’t what you’re using. It’s how, when, or how much you’re using it.

For ADHD brains especially, routines can feel like a trap. If they are too rigid, we rebel, and if it’s too flexible and we forget. So “changing your routine” might mean:

  • Scaling back to fewer steps
  • Switching your application method
  • Adjusting the time you apply products
  • Or, when necessary, swapping products, but with care
Esthetician tip: Never (and I mean never) add more than one new product at a time. You might get away with doing this a few times, but all it takes is one bad mix to wreck your skin barrier and leave you guessing which product did the damage. You’ll lose months of progress and money. (True story.) And for the love of skin, PATCH TEST.

But before we get into the how, let’s dissect the why.

There are a handful of signs people often miss ( subtle and and not-so-subtle) that hint it’s time to make a change.

1. You’re Breaking Out More Than Usual

If your breakouts have increased or changed (more painful, more frequent, different areas), it’s time to reassess and change your skincare routine. Something in your current routine might be clogging, irritating, or just not working anymore. It could also be a sign that your skin barrier is broken.

2. Your Skin Hasn’t Improved in Over 3 Months

If you’ve been consistent for at least 3 months with no noticeable progress (especially with concerns like acne, texture, or dullness), something needs adjusting. It could be your products, technique, or routine timing.

3. You’re Seeing Red, Literally

Stinging, tightness, flaking, or burning aren’t signs your product is “working.” They’re signs of irritation and possibly barrier damage. It’s time to change your skincare routine scale way back.

4. You Keep Forgetting to Do It

If your skincare routine feels like a disappearing act, your setup might be working against you. ADHD brains need visual cues and easy access.

5. It’s Burning a Hole in Your Wallet

Unless you’re on prescribed or medical-grade skincare, your routine shouldn’t be bankrupting you. Skincare shouldn’t be a pain, from shopping, to using, and even facing the receipts. Budget-friendly doesn’t mean ineffective. In fact, simple, soothing routines often outperform expensive 10-step lineups.

So, How Do You Actually Change Your Skincare Routine?

First, take the  “Is My Skin Barrier Damaged?” Test:

✅ Skin Barrier Damage Check:

  1. Does your skin sting, burn, or itch when you apply products?
  2. Are you seeing flaking, tightness, or sudden sensitivity?
  3. Have you recently overloaded your skin with exfoliants, actives, or too many new products?
  4. Is your skin red or unusually shiny, but not in a dewy way?
  5. Does everything feel like it’s making things worse?

If you said yes to any of the above, your barrier might be damaged, and that changes everything.

Check out our full post on how to fix your skin barrier.

If Your Barrier Is Fine, Start With Surrounding Factors

Sometimes the issue isn’t the routine, it’s what’s around it.

Ask yourself:

  1. When’s the last time you changed your pillowcase?
  2. Do you have hard water?
  3. Are you doing your routine right before bed, then smashing your fresh face on the pillow?
  4. Do you touch your face *constantly* without realizing?
Esthetician Tip:  Do your routine at least one hour before bed. And stop touching your face, seriously.

Next: Go Back to Bare Minimum

This is what I call the skincare reset phase, and it’s something I’ve done with real clients who had sudden acne flare-ups.

For 2 weeks, use only:

  1. A gentle, non-stripping cleanser
  2. A calming, hydrating moisturizer

That’s it. No serums. No actives. No masks. This phase is for testing what your skin actually needs. Don’t forget to set aside a few minutes to understand cleansing the right way.

If there’s no improvement in 2 weeks, try swapping your moisturizer first.

Skin TypeProduct NameNotesPrice Range (USD)
Dry / DehydratedCeraVe Moisturizing LotionRich in ceramides + HA; excellent for barrier repair$12 – $18
Etude House Soon Jung 2x Barrier Intensive CreamLightweight but nourishing; calming formula$14 – $18
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Sensitive RicheDeep hydration; safe for sensitive, dry skin$20 – $25
Oily / Acne-ProneEtude House Soon Jung Hydro Barrier CreamLightweight gel-cream with panthenol and centella $12 – $16
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Double Repair Matte MoisturizerMatte finish, niacinamide + ceramides; gentle and breathable$19 – $24
Aveeno Calm + Restore Oat Gel MoisturizerBudget-friendly, fast-absorbing$17 – $20
CombinationAvene Tolerance Control Soothing Skin Recovery BalmSoothes dry areas, balances oil$25 – $30
Aveeno Calm + Restore Oat Gel MoisturizerBudget-friendly, fast-absorbing$17 – $20
Etude House Soon Jung 2x Barrier Intensive CreamLightweight but nourishing; calming formula$14 – $18
Sensitive / ReactiveVanicream Moisturizing CreamUltra-gentle; great for allergies and barrier repair$10 – $14

Try this for another 2 to 3 weeks. Still no luck? Then switch out your cleanser.

Skin TypeProduct NameNotesPrice Range (USD)
Dry / DehydratedInkey List Oat Cleansing BalmRemoves buildup gently; great first step$11 – $14
Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat CleanserCreamy, soothing, and fragrance-free$10 – $13
CeraVe Hydrating CleanserClassic non-stripping option$10 – $15
Oily / Acne-ProneLa Roche-Posay Effaclar Gel CleanserTargets excess oil gently$14 – $18
CeraVe Foaming Facial CleanserRemoves dirt and sebum without over-drying$10 – $15
Simple Refreshing Facial Gel WashClean and budget-friendly$6 – $9
CombinationByoma Creamy Jelly CleanserBarrier-friendly and pH-balanced$12 – $14
Etude House Soon Jung pH 6.5 Whip CleanserSoft, non-stripping foam$10 – $13
Simple Micellar Gel WashMicellar + gel hybrid for balanced cleansing$7 – $10
Sensitive / ReactiveVanicream Gentle Facial CleanserZero fragrance, dye, or parabens$9 – $12
Avene Extremely Gentle Cleanser LotionNo rinse needed; great for inflamed skin$20 – $25
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Hydrating Gentle CleanserCreamy texture, ideal for barrier repair$13 – $17

Once You Stabilize, Change Your Skincare Routine by Adding Products One at a Time

Stabilizing in a new routine takes time, usually 2 to 4 weeks. Don’t rush it or introduce new products if you’re seeing signs like:

  • Redness
  • Itching
  • Flakiness
  • Or any new, unexplained symptom

Let your skin settle first. If it’s reacting, it’s communicating. After this period, you can start with serums or treatments, but patch test and track your skin before adding anything else. The goal is to know what works and what doesn’t before you end up in a full-blown breakout mystery.

How to Change Your Skincare Routine If the Bills Are Piling Up (Or You Keep Forgetting)

Skincare shouldn’t feel like a luxury tax. If your routine is stressing your wallet or just slipping your mind every day here’s how to make it easier and cheaper:

If the Bills Are Getting Out of Hand:

  • Stick to non-glamorous, tried-and-true brands like CeraVe, Cetaphil, or La Roche-Posay. The Inkey List, The Ordinary, Geek & Gorgeous are other good options. They’re not flashy, but they work.
  • Keep it minimal. Cleanser + moisturizer is plenty until your skin demands more.
  • Skip the impulse buys. No one needs five half-used serums.

If You Keep Forgetting to Do It:

Check out our post on ADHD skincare routines that actually work. They have some great tips to help you stick to your routine whether or not you have ADHD. 

  • Move your cleanser to a new, obvious spot in the bathroom so it actually catches your attention.
  • Pair your routine with another habit, like brushing your teeth or taking off your glasses.
  • Set a consistent alarm that you won’t swipe away and forget.
  • Make it easy, fast, and brainless your skin will thank you, and so will your executive function.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

en_USEnglish
Scroll to Top